Housing Doom Housing Bubble Blog

A nation that forgets its past is doomed to repeat it. - Churchill

January 31st, 2007

Twist Speaking at Strategic Edge Meeting on Thursday

Doomers-

If you are in the Tempe, AZ area tomorrow morning,  I’ll be speaking at a meeting of the "Strategic Edge" on the Phoenix housing market.  The meeting will be at 7:30 a.m. at "Jim’s Coney Island Cafe," 1750 N. Scottsdale Rd. in Tempe.  That is at the SW corner of Scottsdale and Cavalier, 1 block south of McKellips and 1 block north of the 202.
Read the rest of this entry »

January 31st, 2007

New Home Sales Report- When Last Month’s Numbers are “Revised”

The New Home Sales Report came out last Friday, and we were told that December prices were up:

The median home price — half sold for more, half for less — rose to $235,000 in December from a downwardly revised $232,200 in November, the Commerce Department said.

The MSM generally neglected to report it, but while the month over month was up, prices were down 1.5% year-over-year. Also of significance, the MSM has the habit of allowing the old revised numbers to fall into the "black hole" of cyberspace, mentioning "downwardly revised", but not giving the former value.  This erases important context and can make the reported rise or fall in price an apples-and-oranges comparison.

The November report made the same claim of rising prices.  However in November there was a positive YOY number, so apparently the media managed to squeeze that number in:

The median price of a new home sold last month [November] rose to $251,700, up 3.2 percent from the October level and 5.8 percent higher than a year ago.

Do you see a problem here?  Last month’s 3.2% price increase- one of the "signs" we were told showed the market was improving- apparently didn’t happen.  The November median price was revised from $251,700 to $232,200 for a 7.7% downward revision.  October’s median price (unrevised) was $248,500 or (revised) $243,600- whichever suits your spin.  Either way, if you used the revised November number, prices were down from the previous month, not up 3.2%. Year-over-year then, the revised prices were DOWN 2.4% YOY, or 4.7% MOM.  These numbers are not adjusted for inflation, and do not reflect builder incentives.

At any rate- Here, for what it is worth, is what the graph looks like: [October and November 2006 numbers have been revised. Data from the Census Bureau.]

Read the rest of this entry »

January 31st, 2007

What Role for the Realtor?

Once more, severe questioning of one of my posts by Doomer Old Mike got me thinking. A few days ago I posted an edited version of a contribution that a realtor submitted to Doom’s Ideas bucket. Old Mike thought this realtor had stepped beyond that profession’s / trade’s proper and customary role when he reflected on market timing, then Old Mike went on to discuss in depth his opinions on where the limits of the realtor’s work should be drawn. As before, I’ve done a bit of editing, added some commentary in footnotes and put in a link or two.

Where I think the benefit in Old Mike’s work lies is in opening up the discussion about what the complementary roles should be in the REIC. It may be inevitable that the present housing downturn will give us tighter regulation of and stiffer training requirements for agents, brokers, and assorted other RE players. Doomers might react to Old Mike’s discussion by contributing their own ideas on where realtors should fit into the post-bubble industry.

Read the rest of this entry »

January 30th, 2007

What’s Behind the Subprime Meltdown?

As of yesterday, our friends at Mortgage Lender Implode-o-meter (MLIOM) were reporting that "Sixteen lenders have now gone kaput."  MLIOM starting tracking these lenders in December, so the rate at which subprimes are closed or sold has been a surprise even to "Doom and Gloomers."

I have tried to find answers from industry insiders, and have particularly appreciated comments on Broker’s Outpost (BO), a site maintained for mortgage brokers, who mainly use BO to look for funding opportunities and advice from each other, but occasionally make more general comments on their industry.

I  was struck by the assessment offered by BO’s gman029 on the problems with the subprime lenders.  He’s a little heavy on the technical jargon, so I have added what translations I could. [Disclosure- I do not speak fluent "mortgagese!"  Comments lightly edited- see link for original.]:
Read the rest of this entry »

January 29th, 2007

Phoenix Home Sales in January- Lereah Please Take Note

One of Doom’s favorite agents sent this report to me last night:

 

January 2007

ALL MLS
 
Active                    44,865 [up 7.3% since Jan 4]
Under contract          6,761
Sold                        3,343
[Down 22.4% YOY so far this month, and 2006 was well below 2005]
 
Dec  06 1-27    4,205  Sold
Jan  06 1-27    4,309  Sold
 
Pendings are increasing, but January is looking more and more like a "new bottom".

Please forward to David Lereah!

  Read the rest of this entry »

January 29th, 2007

Realtor Math Invades Canada - Compounding the Error

First the good news. Although the REIC’s self-serving math goof will be repeated in community newspapers [1] for who knows how long, Canada’s serious Mainstream Media really gets it now. Sharp eyed Doomers may have taken note of yesterday’s Canadian Press wire story [2] that confirmed Ben’s commenter tweedle-dee’s criticism of a RE/MAX assertion last Wednesday of 11 percent gains in Canadian real estate over the last 25 years. Looks like I might now have to take back some of the harsh words I handed out to the CBC in last Thursday’s Doom post Realtor Math Invades Canada".

Read the rest of this entry »

January 28th, 2007

Craigslist Points At Possible Subprime Storefront Shutdown

OK, Doomers, we need a few eyeballs on this one.[1] It appears that a Golden Gate Mortgage associate(?), Shahzada Corp. in Newark CA, may be due to have the contents of its office (at least one, anyway) auctioned off on Wednesday. Details from the Craiglist to now below, but check the link for the latest.

Doom informants have suggested both that paperwork might possibly have been left in the (abandoned?) office, and that this is not possible. Anyone physically close to the site might at least check whether it is in fact closed. As well, anyone having an appropriate contact with the parent company (presumably Golden Gate) might want to confirm they’ve got any confidential stuff dealt with. They might also want to confirm this is just an isolated incident.

Read the rest of this entry »

January 28th, 2007

Looking in the Rear View Mirror - a Realtor Reflects

Realtor Steve Presley is hardly the sort of person Doom would consider popping on the Resources list, but recently he submitted a short piece to our Ideas page that deserves a look. The theme is how calling the bottom of the RE crash / correction will be best done in retrospect.

Read the rest of this entry »

January 27th, 2007

Which One Of Us Has Left the Building?

It’s an article of faith that "The Big Lie" just doesn’t work in our society. Nevertheless, the level of jawboning [1] [2] [3] that has cropped up recently to support Goldilocks, the soft landing, and a perception of US economic strength has been astonishing, to say the least. My worry is that either a whole lot of commentators who know more about this stuff than I ever will have completely lost touch with reality — or I’m in serious trouble. :(

Read the rest of this entry »

January 26th, 2007

NOTICE - Twist Taking the Weekend Off

Doom’s Blogger-In-Chief Twist is taking the weekend off (to give her typing / mousing hands a well earned rest), but expects to be back for posts, comments, and e-mails on Monday.  Please direct correspondence to me until then - John [at] HousingDoom [dot] com